Friend/foe individual writers on Hacker News

solaire_oa

solaire_oa on Hacker News

Friends (40)

dash2 8mo ago
This idea isn't uncommon because it's beyond the Overton window, it's uncommon because it is silly and unworkable.* Total fantasy to think you wouldn't fall afoul of free speech, both legally (in the US) and morally.In fact, the author touts as a benefit that you'd stop populists being able to talk to their audience. This is destroying the village of liberal democracy in order to save it!* Absolutely zero thought has been given to how to police the boundaries. Giving a paid speech? Free gifts fo
view on HN →
polluted NaNy ago
FinnLobsien 9h ago
AI and LLMs, in my opinion, are effectively the industrialization of knowledge work.Like it or not, industrialization brought many benefits and we couldn't imagine our modern way of living without it (just think about medicines). Industrial production made so many things so much more accessible for so many people.But an industrialist perspective doesn't care about the process of making stuff, only about the outcome. The shoemakers deep knowledge of leathers, his intuition of all sorts of differe
view on HN →
dextrous 8mo ago
One way that I could imagine a human-only HN could evolve in the coming AI wasteland: motivated individuals join small local groups and are validated face-to-face at meet-ups. Local trusted leads gatekeep their chapter’s posts, and this scalable moderation works up the tree. Bad leaves get culled out reasonably fast, maybe there’s some controls at the top level that let you see more content “lower down the tree” if you’re ok with lower SNR. Latency to get a post widely distributed grows but I do
view on HN →
arjie 1mo ago
Terrific. When I have a free moment I’ll go see if I can push into your network or whatever. Mine is just a pretty dumb list of loginless ban/highlight.
view on HN →
ptnpzwqd 8mo ago
I think this is a reasonable decision (although maybe increasingly insufficient).It doesn't really matter what your stance on AI is, the problem is the increased review burden on OSS maintainers.In the past, the code itself was a sort of proof of effort - you would need to invest some time and effort on your PRs, otherwise they would be easily dismissed at a glance. That is no longer the case, as LLMs can quickly generate PRs that might look superficially correct. Effort can still have been out
view on HN →
_dwt [profile] 8mo ago
I am going to try to put this kindly: it is very glib, and people will find it offensive and obnoxious, to implicitly round off all resistance or skepticism to incuriosity. Perhaps to alienate AI critics even further is the goal, in which case - carry on.But if you are genuinely confused by the attitudes of your peers, try asking not "what do I have that they lack" ("curiosity"?) but "what do they see that I don't" or "what do they care about that I don't"? Is it possible that they are not enthu
view on HN →
nerdjon 8mo ago
There is a certain amount of irony that people try really hard to say that hallucinations are not a big problem anymore and then a company that would benefit from that narrative gets directly hurt by it.Which of course they are going to try to brush it all away. Better than admitting that this problem very much still exists and isn’t going away anytime soon.
view on HN →
tabs_or_spaces 8mo ago
I'm happy for the guy, but am I jealous as well? Well yes, and that's perfectly human.We have someone who vibe coded software with major security vulnerabilities. This is reported by many folksWe also have someone who vibecoded without reading any of the code. This is self admitted by this person.We don't know how much of the github stars are bought. We don't know how many twitter followings/tweets are bought.Then after a bunch of podcasts and interviews, this person gets hired by a big tech com
view on HN →
AnthonyMouse 8mo ago
> The idea that the free market will self-correct and optimize outcomes is a well-documented fantasy.There are far too many documented instances of it actually working to call it a fantasy.> Markets don’t account for externalitiesMarkets aren't expected to account for externalities. Externalities are the things you're supposed to tax.> they concentrate wealth (and therefore political power)You're describing regulatory capture. This is why governments are supposed to have limited powers. To keep
view on HN →
bodge5000 9h ago
My thoughts remain the same since I've been hearing "months or a year" for the past 5 years. Maybe this time truly is different, but unless acceptance of super-intelligence is required to take some action (most people I've seen who hold this view also don't think it should be seriously regulated so I'm not sure what that would be), why not just wait until it happens rather than making more predictions? The only thing I've ever seen come out of these predictions is willing me to "stop resisting",
view on HN →
mppm 8mo ago
There is a lot of talk about how LLMs will disrupt software development and office work and whatnot, but there is one thing that they are massively disrupting right now, and that is education. I've witnessed this with a group of CS master students recently, and they have let their programming skills atrophy to barely imaginable levels. LLMs have the twin effect of raising the bar for what even a barely viable junior developer has to live up to, while simultaneously lowering their actual skills.
view on HN →
g947o 8mo ago
I am not going to trust a single word from a company whose business is selling you AI products.
view on HN →
ckcheng 8mo ago
There really is a few comments here with great suggestions for how to improve your resume and online presence. It seems like some of it can still be tried, or if you feel it was already tried but got rolled back, then they can be tried again altogether.Unfortunately, there's also a lot of noise here too... As a start, I'd say these few comments have solid, specific, actionable suggestions:- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43978225- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43978405- https://new
view on HN →
MonkeyClub 18d ago
It upsets me somewhat that they’re protesting things like lock-in only after being laid off, while beforehand they were the ones implementing them.I do like the paradox (oxymoron?) of being made redundant with AI, so they’re using AI to render their former companies redundant.But in the end it pushes for more AI software; I’m not sure who wins.
view on HN →
mooreds 7mo ago
haha, no worries.> what are you submission habits? Do you just submit links you find interesting often?Pretty much. I will often email myself links I think might be interesting, then batch up submissions. I also like to highlight friends' posts.> And does the karma rewards factor into your routine submissions?It's always fun to get karma, but I like the fact I can call attention to someone or something that deserves it more.I also wrote and talked about my thoughts on HN and how to be a good com
view on HN →
theshrike79 8mo ago
I've been trying to manifest Web of Trust coming back to help people navigate towards content that's created by humans.A system where I can mark other people as trusted and see who they trust, so when I navigate to a web page or in this case, a Github pull request, my WoT would tell me if this is a trusted person according to my network.
view on HN →
imiric 7mo ago
Hey, that's a perfectly reasonable stance, and I can relate to it.Apologies for working around it and putting the code out there against your wishes. If you check my post history, you can see how opposed I am to these new tools, and "vibe coding" specifically. In my defense, I really didn't want to spend a lot of time on this, and LLMs do a decent job at this type of mechanical conversion. And I really don't judge anyone for using them mindfully, as you've clearly done in this case. The code did
view on HN →
rohansood15 8mo ago
Students want the diploma because it has value. It has value because a student can only get it by learning and problem-solving.If students find a way to get a diploma without doing the work, it will soon be worth less than the paper on which it is printed.
view on HN →
rglover 8mo ago
> How is this the fault of AI? It flagged a possible match. A live human detective confirmed it.Because we're seeing the first instances of what reality looks like with AI in the hands of the average bear. Just like the excuse was "but the computer said it was correct," now we're just shifting to "but the AI said it was correct."Don't underestimate how much authority and thinking people will delegate to machines. Not to mention the lengths they'll go to weasel out of taking responsibility for a
view on HN →
kiesel 8mo ago
I love the fact that the author "wrote" this page with massive CSS framework (tailwind) and some sort of Javascript framework, with a bundler and obfuscator - instead of a plain, simple HTML page. Well played! :-)
view on HN →
jryio 8mo ago
These comments are comical. How hard is it to understand that human beings are experiential creatures. Our experiences matter, to survival, to culture, and identity.I mourn the horse masters and stable boys of a century past because of their craft. Years of intuition and experience.Why do you watch a chess master play, or a live concert, or any form of human creation?Should we automate parts of our profession? Yes.Should he mourn the loss of our craft. Also yes.
view on HN →
alexpotato 8mo ago
One of my favorite stories about logistics and quarterly earnings deadlines (from when I worked at a pharmaceutical company:"In our business, a truckload of various drugs can easily reach $10-$15 million. Now, if that truck arrives at the depot at 11:59pm March 31st then it's first quarter earnings. If it arrives at 12:01am April 1st then it's second quarter earnings.$15 million is a BIG shortfall, even for us, so you better believe those truck drivers will roll the stop signs, blow red lights e
view on HN →
TrevorFSmith 18d ago
If they didn't want us to use other people's ideas without permission then why did they use other people's ideas without permission to make the ideal tool for using other people's ideas with permission?
view on HN →
x0x0 8mo ago
Yeah, this is just long-form linkedin slop. He's thought-leadering to get you to get his (no-doubt slop-written) guides and do leadgen for his forthcoming saas.sigh.
view on HN →
follower 8mo ago
For historical context, the Advogato site in question: https://web.archive.org/web/20170715120119/http://advogato.o...Background on the "trust metric" implemented on the site: https://web.archive.org/web/20160304000542/https://advogato....Apparently my account on the site is/was now more than a quarter of a century old... Gonna try to avoid thinking on that too deeply. :DThere's been a non-zero number of occasions since that time where I've observed situations that mirror the trust-based challen
view on HN →
abathologist 8mo ago
I think we are going to be seeing a vast partitioning in society in the next months and years.The process of forming expressions just is the process of conceptual and rational articulation (as per Brandom). Those who misunderstand this -- believing that concepts are ready made, then encoded and decoded from permutations of tokens, or, worse, who have no room to think of reasoning or conceptualization at all -- they will be automated away.I don't mean that their jobs will be automated: I mean tha
view on HN →
hinkley 1d ago
I have alternated between I don’t get paid enough to worry about this and you don’t pay me enough to shut up about this.The thing is that people want a nice life, and most smart people know that martyring themselves will neither save the world nor give them a good life.The rational thing to do is walk the rim of the proverbial canyon, staying close enough to make good money but far enough away from the Big Questions to never feel like they should become your responsibility to sort out. Because o
view on HN →
oxag3n 8mo ago
Wait a second, did they measure exposure from Claude logs and just assumed impact?Let's say I sell snake oil and I survey every buyer, trying to convince everyone doctors won't be needed in the future.First conclusion is that retired population seeks medical services the most (reality check - according to CDC most doctor visits are for infants).Second conclusion is that because it's a snake oil, it heals all the problems and those people will never return to outdated healthcare system.
view on HN →
brainwipe 8mo ago
I've accidentally been using an AI-proof hiring technique for about 20 years: ask a junior developer to bring code with them and ask them to explain it verbally. You can then talk about what they would change, how they would change it, what they would do differently, if they've used patterns (on purpose or by accident) what the benefits/drawbacks are etc. If they're a senior dev, we give them - on the day - a small but humorously-nasty chunk of code and ask them to reason through it live.Works r
view on HN →
idle_zealot 8mo ago
Or, and I beg you to consider this radical position: we arrest people who break the law (insider trading is illegal) and those who knowingly help them to do so (the operators of the prediction markets).How quickly we accept the death of even the ideal of rule of law in favor of embracing a return to an explicit rule by might, fuck-you-got-mine mentality.
view on HN →
dang 8mo ago
We're going to at least restrict Show HNs for a while.I do think this is relevant though: "HN can't be immune from macro trends" - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
view on HN →
tomhow 8mo ago
> I furthermore wish that "posting an LLM-generated comment (i.e. and passing it off as your own)" was worthy of an instant banIt pretty much is. It’s not hard and fast (sometimes we’ll warn people or email them to ask if it’s not certain) and it takes time for us to see things and act, especially when people don’t email us when they see these comments.But as a general rule, accounts that post generated comments get banned.
view on HN →
jaredklewis 8mo ago
I mean if people had to pay $9.99 per application that would drastically reduce spam applications. So the mail proposal still has a good effect here.
view on HN →
context NaNy ago
jquery NaNy ago
jaustin 8mo ago
I have a Clicks Keyboard and love it. As far as I can tell the team behind the Clicks are pretty intertwined with https://www.fxtec.com/ - in that FX Tech staff seem to be involved in Clicks support, etc.The Clicks Keyboard for iPhone (14) was a great concept, and pretty well executed for a V1 - I haven’t tried their follow-up devices.But assuming it’s the same team, there’s a history of shipping devices behind them.(That isn’t to encourage you to pre-order! Just to perhaps contribute some more
view on HN →

Foes (26)

> the 1950's were so good is because the USA had just won the largest war in history without any damage to the homelandSo why did the UK also see the emergence of a strong middle class which has since eroded?
view on HN →
rexpop 1d ago
Ok, so just do what you think will work, instead?At my job we basically have unlimited AI budget and nobody is forced to do anything. We are all constantly negotiating our impact on one another.
view on HN →
esalman 24d ago
I have a completely different perspective on this.During the day, I am using Opus 5.5 to develop solutions our team would never think was possible two years ago.Ar night I am watching my 5yo learn how to read and do math. The sense of accomplishment he shows being able to add double digits is contagious.Nothing is mundane. One man's basic work is another man's magic. When we have appreciation for each other, we advance more as a species.
view on HN →
bko 24d ago
It's funny you compare it to bicycle racing rather than automotive technology which I imagine you would have to concede that pushing the frontier of things like fuel efficiency and safety would be good.This stuff reads as cope by scientists who spent their entire careers chasing these problems. The idea that someone was just around the corner to solving a problem that's been outstanding for decades, and the model used their brilliant recent insights to crack it (ignoring the cutoff date, that wo
view on HN →
felixgallo 26d ago
We as a society have to cut this low effort commenting out. The documentation is perfectly comprehensible. What action would you take differently if a given feature were implemented by Claude, or a human?
view on HN →
freediddy 7mo ago
That's an interesting list. I think that the humans that will make the most progress in the next few years are the ones that push themselves up to the highest level of that list. Right now is a period of intense disruption and there are many coders that don't like the idea that their way of life is dead. There are still blacksmiths around today but for the most part it's made by factories and cheap 3rd world labor. I think the same is currently happening with coding, except it will allow single
view on HN →
context NaNy ago
jquery NaNy ago
mmaunder 8mo ago
That's one way to block those pesky young innovators from trampling our lawn.
view on HN →
polluted NaNy ago