Friend/foe individual writers on Hacker News

_dwt

_dwt on Hacker News

Friends (87)

orphereus 9h ago
I'm pretty sure most of them are bots. Most of them just ignore the post and comment something that should help the LLM bandwagon continue for a few more days
view on HN →
ecshafer 1d ago
The worst thing about the top AI companies is that they are based in San Francisco, and comes with it the latent cultural attitudes of controlling what other people do. They from the start made these amazing technologies, and then also decided they MUST tell you how you are allowed to use it. Of course they also are lying in bed with the "AI safety" doomsday cult. Chinese models get a few weird results the Chinese government forces them in, but at least they don't scold me for the lack of divers
view on HN →
0c3ca83 2d ago
Yes, what are the negative consequences of being able to fake anything? I can only think of several bookshelves of speculative sci fi, and a number of movies, exploring this.
view on HN →
bobson381 2d ago
There's a sense in which AI is the most distilled iteration of what Paul Kingsnorth calls the machine - at its core the concept is that prickles can replace goo [0]. I think this is part of why the "getting left behind" language is a catalyst, because some people hear it and think, "good, I would like to be left behind". What will remain to be seen is how things play out for the machine itself. Yes, we are intertwined with its fate, but we don't have to be completely enthralled to it.Tied to thi
view on HN →
PaulRobinson 2d ago
I think the next 20 years are going to be fascinating as we see a 21st century equivalent of the 1960s hippy movement, rooted in humanism and prioritising the environment.I wasn't there (no, not like that, I wasn't born yet), but my understanding is that the 1960s movements - there were several - are often reduced to a near caricature of being about drugs and sex.They were a reaction to the horrors of war both real in WW2 ending 15 years earlier, and perceived as the Cold War developed. Escapism
view on HN →
233mhz 2d ago
> How do you combat it?You cannot publicly discuss the few options that might work for legal and moral reasons, but imho it'll end up like it always does when people get more and more alienated.
view on HN →
myaccountonhn 2d ago
Not true, we can absolutely keep AI companies accountable and make them pay for the work their stealing. Engage politically.
view on HN →
kergonath 2d ago
> This is a classic. It’s not businesses and their business models; it’s the Invisible and Inevitable Hand of Progress. You may fight the businesses, but the “progess” is inevitable.As someone once said: there is no alternative.(Except that, of course, there are alternatives, they just really want you to shut up and stop trying to improve things for normal people).
view on HN →
uludag 3d ago
It's okay to just not want or like AI data centers. People don't have to hold a watertight argument against them to oppose them.And with how secretive a lot of those behind these constructions have been, I think everyone is within their right to crank their cynicism towards data centers to the max.
view on HN →
GoToRO 4d ago
My guess is a total disrespect for actually qualified people. You know, the ones that specialized in one thing, for their whole life. Every company tries to see how few people they can have and still run fine. And move fast. And no trainings. And no recognition for the people that could actually train other people. I think all these come together at some point and you get multiple catastrophic events in multiple industries.
view on HN →
aislophater 4d ago
Oh wow, ai slop that is barely the same quality as the first iphone apps. This site is garbage. Thanks to AI the talentless finally have a voice. Whoopie.
view on HN →
Avicebron 7d ago
This is jumping the real world concerns into the realm of science fiction. How about we engage with the premise that before the AGI god comes into being and annoints the Rationalists as it's chosen people, there will be people who will try and use this to enrich themselves and immiserate others.
view on HN →
ricardobayes 7d ago
Apologize for strong words, and sorry, nothing personal, but I find this mindset bizarre and even comical. Will we reach a stage where surgeons on the operating table will second-guess their experience and education and refer to an AI assistant?
view on HN →
customguy 7d ago
That's exactly my point, programming isn't your IT department, "cool things that can be done with computers" isn't even on speaking terms with it, and the web is not a sector of marketing, either. Bores turn everything they touch boring, and now they're telling us we'll be left behind. And I'm like, YES, finally, can't wait, what can I do to accelerate it?
view on HN →
unknownian 7d ago
GenAI that imitates human art is the definition of an anti-invention. If an invention is a new innovation that improves something for the human experience, an anti-invention is a new innovation that makes life worse.This is just one of several areas where GenAI has been harmful and should start getting regulated like digital drugs.
view on HN →
Zigurd 10d ago
Anyone want to claim that all the people leaving have Trump derangement syndrome? Anyone? Bueller?Anyone want to claim that the normies like techno fascism? Anyone want to claim that it was smart to line up behind Trump at the inauguration? Did you benefit from that?Idiots who thought they were the smartest people in the room is who.
view on HN →
Dem_Boys 16d ago
This comment section blows my mind! Are we that insulated from the world? Are these all bots? Am I crazy???Tech is now viewed in the same lense as dirty greedy oil companies. If an oil company opened a candy store most people I know would not go because "Oh those oil companies can't be trusted"Anytime I talk to anyone not in tech they're extremely sceptical of anything tech companies do. Most common reasons I hear as to why is greed, social media destroying children in many ways, seeking p
view on HN →
rurp 16d ago
Exactly. The most baffling thing about the backlash is how shocked the tech boosters are at it. I know tech can be a bubble, but it's stark to see just how out of touch people inside can be.Most American's lives have been made worse by AI so far, rather than better. They are deeply skeptical that future gains will be freely shared with them rather than horded by a few tech oligarchs. Based on pretty much all of modern history, they're right to be skeptical.This is apparently incomprehensible to
view on HN →
pucas946 16d ago
The literal pitch these guys have been using is:* We've built a technology that has obliterated entry level hiring* That technology might obliterate all the other "normal" person white collar jobs. The kinds of jobs you can clock in and out and not think about them outside of that. Instead, every new job will be a managerial one working with 500 agents.* Loaning all the money to build these data centers and train these models costs so much it cranks rates through the roof, so we've frozen the re
view on HN →
softwaredoug 21d ago
Just makes me think how we have encouraged a generation of tech leaders to be complete assholes with no consequences. That “loser thinking” line should never be accepted in any company discourse, even from leadership. If this person wasn’t an exec, they’d be shown the door for that language.Have people completely lost their humanity? Is winning at whatever you’re doing that important we can’t be equally obligated to show each other decency?
view on HN →
bunderbunder 23d ago
I'm not him, but I would guess that he would respond by saying that we have a moral and ethical responsibility to remain in control of what we're putting into the world. If there's a conflict between the given timelines and how quickly a human can understand the problem and the implications of the decision being made, then the thing that needs to budge is the timeline.
view on HN →
ryandvm 1mo ago
My favorite part about gushing about the new age of AI development is how oblivious the authors always seem to be about the next phase.It's always some variation of: the LLMs are incredible and gaining logical and reasoning ability at an astounding rate, but fortunately they will always need me to sit here to hit the "Enter" key.I envy their optimism.
view on HN →
lsy 1mo ago
I imagine this is like how microwaves put restaurants out of business, how TTS obviated literacy, how the automobile age made it unnecessary to walk, how Zoom caused every office to close, how helicopters put mountaineering firmly behind us, Amazon obsoleted brick and mortar stores, and payment cards made cash disappear.It's not only ahistorical to fail to consider preferences and politics, but it's also an indictment of the author's ability to judge the quality of a machine output versus that o
view on HN →
simoncion 1mo ago
> 2. I wouldn't be surprised at some unexpectedly large amount of AstroTurfing, especially considering the sheer amount money is flowing into the AI space.Given the soul-crushingly large amounts of money sloshing around in this tiny slice of the industry, the amount of astroturfing, positive-sentiment manufacturing, & etc. is right about where I expect it to be... as is the amount of vehement denial that it exists. ;)
view on HN →
winwang 1mo ago
I am a programmer who likes aesthetics. I think about how aesthetic it is to not have to deal with certain production incidents for certain blocks of code because the typelevel computation tells me it would be a compiler bug if it screwed up. I like the feeling of realizing those 100 LOC could just be 10.I sometimes tell people of when I came down from Mt. Fuji, there were wispy clouds and grand nature below me, picturesque like a painting. At that time, I likened it to the beauty I felt when I
view on HN →
voidhorse 1mo ago
You ought to apply your own standards to your own comments.The OP is an article that:1. Raises a number of broad social and ethical concerns about AI. 2. Provides links to back up some of these claims.Yes, it also vents some frustration and includes personal anecdote, but there's nothing wrong with that. If you think something is a net negative for society, you should be frustrated. That doesn't make an argument "unreasonable" or "not well thought out". In fact, your entire response to the artic
view on HN →
adityaathalye 1mo ago
My word, my whole blog is antipatterns (probably because I write it for me :D). Like, look at these doozies (all have lengthy preambles). There are more, but these cover all the antipatterns mtlynch mentioned. I am not at all sad, rather I am chuckling because when one doesn't care who reads the post, one can get away with such ghastly antimatter :DAnd, allow me to add antipattern no. N, in full display in the posts below: A 1:1 ratio of main body to footnotes, because we want some place to put
view on HN →
whateveracct 1mo ago
people actually are saying if you keep coding by hand you will be left behindmy CEO said it publicly to all engineershe still pays me for my handwritten code tho. luckily it's easy to pretend you like AI and know by lying since it has basically no skill curve.and then just carry on doing a good job the old way.
view on HN →
honeycrispy 1mo ago
It sounds like you never enjoyed coding.If the discussion was "Sitting in a submarine is not as fun as scuba-diving", I would recognize the conversation is not about me, and not jump in and tell all of the recreational scuba-divers they're wrong.
view on HN →
seki285 1mo ago
That's a valid assessment, and a reminder why I keep using 4chan despite how awful it is.
view on HN →
nearlyepic 1mo ago
Boy look at all these six month old accounts that have been programming for decades and just love vibe coding!
view on HN →
munificent 1mo ago
> Right now, we have (most of) my undergrad classmates' dream industry. They drink constantly [1], skip lectures, scrape by on their homework with AI, complain about classes, grind Leetcode to get internships, and eventually get their diploma. It must feel like walking around in a literal dream, where your footsteps have no weight, like Wile E. Coyote near a ledge.There is a name for this in sociology: anomie [1].In times of great change, the set of norms and rules that we take for granted as an
view on HN →
Toutouxc 1mo ago
This seems overly reductive. I’m firmly in the second camp, I don’t enjoy typing code, I want to be solving real world problems, not riddles. But I don’t consider a problem solved until I have understood it entirely, until I’ve anchored that new piece of understanding within my mental model of the domain, until I feel like I’m able to deploy that knowledge on demand and build upon it.Working with AI tools the way many people seem to be doing it (multiple sessions at once, not even reading the ou
view on HN →
tarkin2 1mo ago
So far I've seen- AI make a number of programmers redundant and their work is replaced with code of dubious quality and uncertain ability to maintain. The same is true for QAs and designers.- young and old replace human friendship, and fostering their social skills, for conversations with their AI bot- people avoid using their brain or practicing their skills in favour of asking some LLM- people's work stolen, with the possibility of an AI subscription in return- the laws on hacking and thief ig
view on HN →
david927 1mo ago
We're getting so much of this junk with the IPOs pressing.The mimicbots are impressive but they're frustrating. We've hit the limit for pre-training data and now we're relying on RL for the next progressive steps and that gets asymptotic fast. The truth is that unsupervised learning hasn't inched forward and we don't know how it will, so we're left with benchmaxxing and LARPing about how they're escaping air-gapped configs using themal sensors, all in a desperate attempt to make the projected
view on HN →
lbrito 1mo ago
"Am I allowed to say that?" - no.You are allowed to be optimistic; pessimists are "losers" (dhh - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDjW_dRyKXY).You are just throwing a temper tantrum (https://archive.is/YNxJq).Do not commit blasphemy against AI. (https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/talk-bubble-i...)
view on HN →
eudamoniac 1mo ago
We've entered the "AI is good and inevitable and only pretentious people would write their own words" phase of the forum.
view on HN →
applfanboysbgon 1mo ago
Gross how many commenters are swarming to take pride in their ignorance and generation of deficient, bug-ridden code. Like actual cockroaches, there's 15 one-line comments to this effect in 10 minutes. LLMs are obviously immensely useful for certain types of tasks and prototyping but you have to be seriously incompetent if they're faster and better than you are for writing production code in any area where you have the slightest bit of expertise.
view on HN →
jacquesm 2mo ago
It's the robbery of all of our culture to sell it back to us at a mark-up. Crimes this large are crimes against humanity. So many people whose life's work got appropriated without consideration, compensation or consent it is baffling.It is said that at the heart of every great fortune there is a great crime, so it should be no surprise that the most valuable companies on the planet will most likely result from this crime. And given that justice can be bought by those with the most money you can
view on HN →
mancerayder 2mo ago
I'm very senior and in a HCOL, relatively booming city. It's never been so hard to find a job despite never being so qualified. I can code, run infra, scale startups, do hands on, manage, present, I can do anything. But that's not what they are looking for. Dozens and dozens of my applications are rejected, with no first screens.The same resume, just with a few less years experience at the same place, just a few years ago got recruiter pings.It's insane and I'm very worried about the future
view on HN →
BigTTYGothGF 2mo ago
Ah, the good old "outside agitators" canard.> These new AI data centers are now built with their own power generation capacityAnd now you've got all the noise and pollution from that to deal with.
view on HN →
recursivedoubts 2mo ago
> Why it mattersContinue to pray to Yellowstone. Concentrate on the magma chamber. We can end it here, we can end it for all time.
view on HN →
hi_im_greg_h 2mo ago
Interesting that you use self driving as the metaphor here, when we've been told for years that self driving will be taking over the roads any day now... and yet...
view on HN →
bigstrat2003 2mo ago
Yep. I think that AI tech has turned out to be pretty much the worst thing the tech industry has ever created. It is a huge net negative for the entire world, and even for the very profession which created it.
view on HN →
lo_zamoyski 2mo ago
> what the point of doing research was if someone like Terence Tao could have figured out everythingA similar question is now being asked: what is the point of doing research, etc. if something like AI can figure out everything?The question betrays the parochial way in which many people think about knowledge. For them, knowledge is merely an instrument or an effect. It does not occur to them that knowing is a valuable thing in itself, that understanding is valuable and desirable. Yes, some knowl
view on HN →
AmazingEveryDay 2mo ago
The bots see a simonwillison.net post, the bots upvote. ffs.
view on HN →
mbgerring 2mo ago
If you’re one of the people wondering why there’s an enormous backlash to AI, here’s your answer: “this thing we’re building is going to he fucking terrible and ruin your life. Please give us all your money to build it.”
view on HN →
ThrowawayR2 2mo ago
> "Where are all the crazy ones, the misfits, the rebels?"They've been driven underground or entirely out of software by the mundanes but pointing that out draws huffy accusations of "gatekeeping".
view on HN →
31aH172 2mo ago
Telling the peasants to suppress anger is the primary means of the ruling classes to induce inaction.Righteous anger is a healthy and natural response. Those who admonish others to "be curious", to "wait and see", to "be rational" often have an agenda.Like this author who is invested in AI.
view on HN →
jszymborski 2mo ago
> Who are you going to be angry at and why are you angry in the first place? One narrative that is pretty pervasive is that if AI will usher in productivity gains, those gains are going to benefit companies rather than employees. And well at least someone at Meta wants that.> [...]> My answer to the question of how you can not be angry in tech is that it’s by no way the most only possible feeling. First of all, instead of being angry, you can simply be unsure. The feeling of uncertainty is a muc
view on HN →
dan_ggggg 2mo ago
That's the whole scam. It's a ransom with more steps.First they fuck up your codebase with so much slop that no human does (or could) understand it.Now if you want to keep making bug fixes, you're on the hook for whatever Anthropic wants to charge you.The solution is to make AI developers the scapegoat. Fire the people at the top of the AI leaderboards, with malice. Otherwise, lazy AI-addict developers are going to destroy what remains of your company's IP.
view on HN →
ceejayoz 2mo ago
> If much of the population is too poor to buy anything, too sick to consume much etc - who is left to buy anything at all?No one. That's the idea.A low-population paradise. Venice without its pesky people to mess with Bezos's wedding. Bora Bora without the peasants.
view on HN →
metalman 2mo ago
the future is here, it's just not evenly distrubuted conversly, there is no human technology that isn't still bieng practiced in it's original form, ie: there are still people knapping stone tools that learned it from there parents and grandparents going on strait back to the first members of our "species" who learned it from there hybrid parents, in an unbroken chain, which is directly connected to ALL modern technology, in that early metal working was done with stone tools, as metal was far to
view on HN →
keybored 3mo ago
You know, I think I’ve had enough of “have taken up farming”/woodworking Silicon Valley nostalgics at this point (I’m talking about them/in general, not you).Modern computing is toxic. The Internet is shit. And all because it was designed that way. Computing doesn’t have to be shit. I would know. Plenty of let’s say local computing solutions are just fine. They are so okay and fine that I hardly think about them. They just save me time and work.Like the AI Cretins say, the cat’s out of the bag,
view on HN →
nullc 3mo ago
They're acting as a meatbot being piloted by the AI. Could call them skroders.It should be the other way around-- you give the AI instructions and it does stuff. Any time the AI is giving you instructions and you do stuff, that should be a big red flag.
view on HN →
JohnMakin 3mo ago
You can tell the people pioneering this are utterly miserable and soulless. "Let's build something to automate all the parts of your life that are actually your life."What person that was even mildly satisfied with living their life would want this? What's next, agents that play video games and watch tv for me? What's the point?
view on HN →
apsurd 3mo ago
but why is it a tired argument?You'd clearly never believe this but there's even an argument that cars are of dubious benefit to society. Personal/passenger cars mostly in that they've reshaped our entire civilized landscape to be inhumane and all the long-term and downstream health effects that that entails.
view on HN →
mccoyb 3mo ago
I mean, it feels hard not to laugh at this type of blog post. My cynical interpretation is that this is a type of passing the buck to engineers in enterprise settings ("Stop spending tokens. Did you read the value maximization blog post? It is your fault.")Oh yes, Claude will do all sorts of different things -- it depends on how you use it! You should totally learn all of these little finicky things ... because now completing your tasks cost money. It's not "free" anymore haha like when you used
view on HN →
no_multitudes 3mo ago
"And when the floor goes, the thing that decides what is worth keeping is no longer the cost of making it."I'm 100% confident that a human did not write this sentence unless they were deliberately trying to sound like an LLM. Just look at it! You don't need Pangram. There's a classifier model between your ears that knows how humans write.
view on HN →
Tiberium 3mo ago
Those people should just try posting a big quote from the article to HN, and then see their comment get instantly flagged due to HN's AI detection (which might as well be Pangram)It's baffling to me how people are so dismissive of Pangram despite never using it, extrapolating their experience from GPTZero or something else.
view on HN →
noir_lord 3mo ago
> I'm often enough surprised that our society runs.It runs because there are just enough people who know what they are doing and quietly do it often against headwinds in just about all the places they need to be.Which works until it doesn't, We've gradually been removing those people in the name of "efficiency" with somewhat predictable systemic results across the board.
view on HN →
daun_gee 3mo ago
The slur is necessary to convey the total dysfunction of LLM chat bots.A human being as exceptionally stupid as an LLM chatbot could not possibly get hired for any type of job. A human being as exceptionally stupid as an LLM chatbot is too stupid to survive.To say that LLM chat bots are "slow" or "stupid" or "misleading" is to misrepresent how terribly inadequate their performance is.
view on HN →
artyom 3mo ago
I guess it depends on your definition of "too much", but also on your definition of "thinking".What I've found is that LLMs are excellent tools for:- Spitting out white collar corporate speak that sounds plausible to other corporate speakers- Hugely accelerating the process of going through academia which, except for a few specific cases, is essentially years of copy/pasting- Writing code as long as such code as been written many times before- Figuring out which one of the 10 ads and 12 misleadi
view on HN →
dofm 3mo ago
Ed Zitron is enjoyably mouthy and rude about AI and AI people, but it’s a bit of a stretch to suggest that someone most people have never heard of helped create the AI backlash. He is just putting it into words.You know what created the AI backlash as well as anyone, and it is: AI and AI people.If e/acc voices were not so abrasively, obtrusively YOLO about their technology, if their entire take on what they earn millions to do was not so easily reduced to “yeah it sucks that your job will go awa
view on HN →
palmotea 3mo ago
> AI investment will crash but AI itself (the technology) will continue thriving, learning, improving and there is absolutely no way to stop it.No, there's is a way to stop it. As obvious counterexample: go all Butlerian Jihad: death sentence for anyone caught "making a machine in the likeness of a human mind." It's doable with a few laws and treaties. I'm not saying that's the only way it could be stopped, it's just a way it could.I'm fucking sick of TINA, especially with arguments from vigorou
view on HN →
connorboyle 3mo ago
I gave it a question I've been trying to answer for a long time: "What star designation system does Joseph Needham use in Science & Civilization in China? What star is referred to by the designation '4339 Camelopardi' in that book"?Fable blew me away with its detailed answer[0] showing a chain of references going from J. E. Bode's 1801 catalogue Allgemeine Beschreibung und Nachweisung der Gestirne to Gustave Schlegel's 1875 work Uranographie Chinoise. I was excited, until I checked scanned copie
view on HN →
lardosaurusrex 3mo ago
People often question me how I manage to focus for more than a few minutes and I'm always confused because back in the day I was constantly informed I didn't have any focus and needed to be treated (adhd).I'm not convinced attention spans themselves have changed; I think it has more to do with the fact that people's brains aren't defaulting to daydreaming anymore when bored.I think it's still an issue with people being addicted to phones because I'm sure the lack of daydreaming -- which studies
view on HN →
malfist 4mo ago
It sure is funny how everyone claims the current model is a "dramatic improvement" over the models from X months ago.You'd think if there had been that many dramatic improvements I'd have to babysit an LLM less frequently.
view on HN →
vrganj 4mo ago
I'm not sure I've seen what I would call dramatic improvement since maybe GPT4?Sure, things got better. But I'd call it iterative more than revolutionary. I still wouldn't trust any of the models to do anything meaningful unattended. They all still do dumb shit all the time.Plus, even if they were genuinely dramatically better, the businesses sure as hell aren't. They're burning money left and right, they have no moat, Chinese open models are basically equivalent these days. What's the path to p
view on HN →
dan_i 4mo ago
> More folks should join us in open mockery of hypocritical whinging from technological robber barons.This is not tolerated in any capacity on hackernews.My account is shadowbanned. Maybe you can see this if you have some setting enabled.The forum is entirely hostile to criticisms of "AI". They'll ban you if you don't preface your critique with "AI has made me 20x more productive BUT"
view on HN →
stego-tech 4mo ago
And to think I got warned in another post that I need to be nicer/more professional in discussing this topic.Yeah. Nah.Bringing out the same drum I’ve been banging for years now, these companies have never actually cared about ensuring safe AI, regulation, or ensuring it benefits all humanity. It has always, always, been about control and their profit margins. Their actions have never reflected any sort of positive, shared human benefit since OpenAI released ChatGPT, and they’ll never actually p
view on HN →
arnitdo 4mo ago
in: Making
How does this even contribute to the content posted?The only thing being "redefined" is corporate agendas to push the bar of "good enough" lower to the point where it lies below cheap, and equals wasteful.
view on HN →
slopinthebag 4mo ago
Do you actually believe this and are concerned about it?
view on HN →
sublinear 4mo ago
> If we’re building a software factory, details matter. The details that establish architectural patterns. Down to algorithms and performance. Agents push us to evaluate, measure, and guard. They’ve made it cool to add CI into side projects early, not as an afterthought. That’s massive improvement to the state of software.Why are you building a software factory though, and why weren't you immediately adding CI to every project?> It’s our job to build the software factory - not just the software.
view on HN →
flohofwoe 4mo ago
It's a "bring your own renderer" UI framework, just like Dear ImGui or Nuklear. In some situation (e.g. when adding debugging UIs to a game) this is actually a big advantage compared to the renderer being baked into the library, since the game already has a renderer subsystem which the UI can easily hook into.
view on HN →
roadside_picnic 4mo ago
It also underplays what I've personally witnessed that I would consider true AI psychosis.I worked with someone who sincerely believed he was spiritually co-evolving with his army of sycophantic AI agents (the agents would be tasked with discussing his thoughts at night and collaborated to give him morning reports about his progress). He would publicly write about how relationships with friends and family collapsing was a natural consequence of being so "advanced". I also never once saw any mean
view on HN →
operatingthetan 4mo ago
Eh not really. It's more like it starts explaining to the user that they are very special, and they discovered this unique intellectual thing in the AI slop that no one ever has, then starts convincing them it's mystical or similar. Just feeding the user magical narcissism basically.
view on HN →
sph 4mo ago
There is no win condition. Despite the usefulness claims of generative AI, it is a net negative on society and on education. Humanity will somehow make do and get used to it; but I doubt the upheaval we will have to go through the next X decades will have any silver lining other than “we made billionaires richer and exponentially increased wealth disparity”I honestly pity watching my fellow software engineers rush to adapt to this new dystopia, just to stay afloat a little while longer before th
view on HN →
beepbooptheory 4mo ago
I simply have no need for these things. I am faster, smarter, and I understand more. I syntesize disparate concepts your SoT models could never dream of. Why should I waste the money? I have all that I need up in my brain.When everyone forgets how to read, I'll be thriving. When everyone is neurotic from prompting-brain, I will be in my emacs, zen and unburdened.I love that yall have them though, they are kinda fun to mess with. And as long as I can review and reject it, all yalls little generat
view on HN →
bryanrasmussen 4mo ago
OK, glad to hear I was mistaken, but it certainly seemed like about halfway through your first response you went off the rails and decided to take my question as some sort of personal affront. It was not the strangest response I've had on HN, but one of the strangest. I could go through with a full analysis of why I thought "this guy is having problems", but that would take a long time and as you say you aren't I guess it isn't particularly useful.I guess we aren't going to get anything meaning
view on HN →
archagon 4mo ago
A new technology comes out — admittedly one that’s extraordinarily capable at some things — and suddenly conventional software engineering is “more or less obviated at this point”? I’m sorry, but that’s really fucking dumb. Do you think LLMs are actually intelligent? Do you think their capabilities exceed the quality of their training corpus? Is there no longer any need to think about new software paradigms, build new frameworks, study computer science, because the regurgitated statistical versi
view on HN →
the_axiom 4mo ago
the story is bad in itself and doesn't add anything to the readerbut if you knew it came from a human it would be interesting as a window to learning what the writer was thinkingsince there is no writer such window doesn't exist either
view on HN →
jquery NaNy ago
forgetfreeman 4mo ago
"reflexive anti AI luddite attitude"That's awfully reductive there, champ. Most critiques of AI are based on some combination of observed failings of the technology, observed failings of the tech industry writ large, and healthy skepticism in the face of Yet Another Tech Industry Hype Typhoon. Anyway, the burden of proof isn't on skeptics, it's on the technology and it's proponents, so let's see some receipts before we agree to squander limited public resources on unproven systems yeah?
view on HN →
context NaNy ago
bluefirebrand 4mo ago
It's not reflexive, I've spent a lot of time and effort considering why I think AI is bad for society.
view on HN →
polluted NaNy ago

Foes (40)

thirtygeo 1mo ago
Incorrect!As a domain expert, I spent all my time learning my scientific niche, and only a small bit on practical coding. Now I can manifest the ideas I formerly needed to hire developers for. WAY more fun.
view on HN →
polluted NaNy ago
jph00 4mo ago
Heaven forbid we let poor people use software that helps their kids read.If they can't afford a tutor, they deserve nothing.(Am I doing this right?)
view on HN →
manlymuppet 1mo ago
I think this is cope. I'm sorry to be so harsh, and the author is entitled to their opinions on what is fun, but I think a lot of the "LLMs are not fun" discourse is motivated reasoning.We can no longer deny that LLMs are useful for coding, so we now move on to the only remaining and defensible goalpost: I don't use LLMs because I don't want to. To be clear, this is a perfectly fine position and I hold no ill will against anybody holding it, but I don't think one gets to this conclusion naturall
view on HN →
tptacek 4mo ago
The introduction to this piece was easy to follow, but as soon as he got into recapitulating it with algebra he lost me (because I'm bad at math). But he includes the GPT5 prompts for his conversation, which are easier to follow:https://chatgpt.com/share/6a5fdc7a-d6f8-83e8-bbea-8deb42cfed...
view on HN →
xiaodai 3mo ago
Amen! Europe used to complain about the US stealing their intellectual property! The nuclear bomb would have been possible if not for Jewish scientists from Europe going to America! So until about 100 years ago, US was FAR behind Europe in technology and science.
view on HN →
casey2 4mo ago
It makes sense, Haskell is basically just python from the code perspective. If it's faster to generate code than to compile it you might as well just keep generating til it works for your specific task.
view on HN →
reactive-shadow 3mo ago
I love that your whole life journey over the last 8 years is on this forum, and seeing Claude unravel your journey with children was so interesting.14 Dec 2019, on "Having Kids" (id=21790724): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21790724"I regret reading this essay because now the discouragement is back. I have wanted children; my wife has not. I am determined not to force the issue as she would be the one undertaking most of the burden, and why should I cause her to resent me? So I made peace
view on HN →
rvz 2mo ago
Good. Increase the subscription prices against what the users think. There are no ads at all. But of course not everyone will agree and want it for free.Many know they want it for free. If you don't pay at all then it will force LWN to begin to place ads on their newsletter to cover the costs.There is no realistic in-between other than actually paying for your services.
view on HN →
simonw 4mo ago
I'm fascinated by how AI poster designs have taken over local advertising in seemingly just the last six months - presumably because ChatGPT Images and Gemini Nano Banana finally got good enough at outputting text without obvious defects in the typography.The posters all look good - much better than their desktop publishing predecessors. And yet they also eat away at the credibility of the event or business for me.It's hard to trust a poster when the quality of the design has zero relation to th
view on HN →
bbor 2mo ago
Not using world-changing technology because some people are using it harmfully is wild. Expanding it to people just making art (/entertainment...) that you don't like is just confusing.Obviously I relate to the anxiety that made this man put up at least 3 mentions of how much he hates AI per page site-wide and to finish this draft before the actual site, but I can't help but see it as an unhealthy coping mechanism.It's a shame cause this is an origami-themed freelance web developer who believes
view on HN →
kragen 1mo ago
It just seems like a lot of hate resulting from dysfunctional responses to life circumstances — admittedly, probably pretty bad life circumstances, from the sound of it. Spreading hate online, especially accompanied by lies as in this case, doesn't seem like a socially positive action from my point of view. The author should have kept it to themself and maybe talked to someone who could give them a better perspective, rather than letting their hate out into the world to multiply.
view on HN →
Oh wow, a low quality comment denigrating the doers. Thank you for your service.
view on HN →
phoghed 1mo ago
Future of Life Institute, Guardrails Alliance, Public First Action, PauseAI, ControlAI.Both sides of this issue are doing the same thing, you’d be a fool to believe otherwise.
view on HN →
mlapeter 2d ago
I agree with it moving away from the things you mentioned, and hope for the most part that a vision like yours is what happens. Though fwiw I don't think it needs to be a man vs machine type of humanism, I'm actually finding there's a lot to learn about what makes us human by interacting with AI. I've been trying to give AI better memory over last several months, and it's taught me just how much of our memory we basically make up, like how our vision fills in the gaps. And how closely tied memo
view on HN →
deadbabe 2mo ago
At some point, LLMs will be a far better source of truth, and then this distaste of people “outside their domains” is really just going to be a sort of snobbery from people who have had experience in a domain for a long time, (but they still have the same level of knowledge and insight as a person who just used an LLM to research).These people are basically nascent “human supremacists”, who believe that only raw human insight and output has value, and is even superior, than equivalent output loo
view on HN →
logicchains 4mo ago
>Most critiques of AI are based on some combination of observed failings of the technologyMost critiques of AI are based on experience with the cheapest AI available a year ago, by midwits unable to recognize that AI's performance on the Putnam, IMO and bar exam makes it far smarter than they are by almost every metric that was traditionally used to measure intelligence.
view on HN →
jdw64 3mo ago
Gen AI text is actually more logical and has fewer gaps in its sentences. When you write with Gen AI, the text becomes densely packed with information. A short piece contains a tremendous amount of content. Human writing is inherently asymmetric, while Gen AI writing tends to be symmetric, embedding too much information within the text.But when we learn to write, we're taught to revise by subtracting, not adding, to strive for reduction rather than expansion. Ironically, I sometimes wonder if wh
view on HN →
budsniffer952 4mo ago
>I still wouldn't trust any of the models to do anything meaningful unattendedNobody cares about your personal hangups about AI. Tons of people are building with it.
view on HN →
CamperBob2 4mo ago
Right, wrong, whatever. The one thing every sane person can agree on is that it's a good thing the Luddites didn't prevail.How much did you pay for the shirt you're wearing now?
view on HN →
llm_nerd 2mo ago
It is backwards in every scenario, and it is basically tilting at windmills. There is a lot of that around, thinking it is making a difference.Guy thinks this is his niche. Everyone will go "that's neat" and move on with life.There was another post on here recently by a translator, whose profession is translating documents, declaring that they won't use AI in their work and anyone who does is a noob and it is no threat to what they do...and it just was amazing stuff. Of course HN pandered to it
view on HN →
csallen 3mo ago
I'm trying to understand your point of view, but it kind of just sounds like you're against learning how to use tools efficiently?I mean, agentic coding software is hardly the first tool to exist where learning some idiosyncrasies of how to use it well can result in more efficiency and cost savings.
view on HN →
simianwords 4mo ago
The intersection of people who like vim and ai is basically nil
view on HN →
ETH_start 8d ago
Instead of just being sad that people die, we should make a conscious collective choice to use the massive AI/SI compute at our disposal to advance the state of medical technology and engineering.
view on HN →
Der_Einzige 4mo ago
The amount of coping, seething etc at the fact that Nvidia is hilariously profitable leads to some of the funniest cognitive dissonance I’ve seen on the internet.
view on HN →
planb 4mo ago
in: Making
Let’s not argue about the meaning of “making”, but that’s a very limited view of how value is created. So in your view the producer or even the director of a movie cannot take pride in it because the actors are the ones doing the work?
view on HN →
the_real_cher 4mo ago
This person is taking things too literally.By power tool we simply mean speeds up work.And by that definition LLMs are absolutely a power tool of epic proprtions!If you ever coded before LLMs existed its like night and day.
view on HN →
qingcharles 3mo ago
It's counter to what sci-fi taught us using AI would be like. We never thought we'd have to feed it words of encouragement, we expected it to act more mechanically, like the computer interfaces we have been using, but here we are. It's kind of quaint, and kind of endearing.
view on HN →
prescriptivist 4mo ago
> We can in fact just NOT do things!I agree with you on that. Not just on AI but a lot of things that suck about this world, and in particular the United States. But capital is too powerful. And these tools are legitimately transformative for business. And business pays our bills and, more importantly, provides the healthcare insurance for our families. The wheel is a real fucking drag isn't it?I don't see anything short of a larger revolution against capital stopping or even stemming this. For
view on HN →
> the 0.1% hold all the wealth and AI powerIs the equivalent of ants trying to outsmart Google that wants to build a datacenter on their land. ASI will unfathomably outsmart the wealthy and intelligent humans like Stockfish 13 does Magnus Carlsen
view on HN →
TeMPOraL 3mo ago
To drive the point about this being fundamentally unsolvable home, imagine a variant of this scenario.I could write an email that is directed towards that person, that says WE ARE STUCK IN THE SERVER ROOM AND THERE IS FIRE STARTING. PLEASE CALL 911 AND ALERT YOUR BOSS.Would you want the human assistant to just dismiss this as a prompt injection attempt? Or ignore it because they were told to treat e-mails as data and never act on them?
view on HN →
pixl97 23d ago
Thank goodness human books never have hidden errors.
view on HN →
notashelf 3mo ago
I'll risk sounding antagonistic and ask you this: if LLMs are not "good enough", why are they still around?Obviously "good enough" was a poor pick of words of words on my behalf---and I'll gladly own it---but they should be "good enough" for something if a significant amount of resources keep getting allocated to them. Yes on a very personal level you look at LLM-generated code and think to yourself "wow this is garbage" but what about the people, as pointed out many times in this thread, that s
view on HN →
quuxplusone 3mo ago
Indeed,> (A writer to the Montgomery (Alabama) Advertiser of 1903-10-24 points out that you can get the apparently-most-common wrong answer if you read the puzzle incorrectly as “She was twice as old as Ann was when Mary [sic] was as old as Ann now is.”)
view on HN →
andrewstuart 3mo ago
Cause they are anti LLM and it seems such people need to not just have their stance but whack everyone with it.
view on HN →
qup 23d ago
> a human can understand the problem and the implications of the decision being madeThese are weasel words that will be used to move the goalposts forever.Guys like the one in the article will argue that we don't understand how AI works, because they don't understand how AI works.They will never take the time to learn. If they do, they will invent a new goalpost.I do strive to understand what I'm building, but probably not in the way you mean, or the way the luddites would demand.The truth is, t
view on HN →
context NaNy ago
jquery NaNy ago
johnfn 4mo ago
Time and time again that I observe it is the AI skeptic that is not reacting with curiosity. This is almost fundamentally true, as in order to understand a new technology you need to be curious about it; AI will naturally draw people who are curious, because you have to be curious to learn something new.When I engage with AI skeptics and I "ask these people what they're really thinking, and listen" they say something totally absurd, like GPT 3.5-turbo and Opus 4.6 are interchangeable, or they pu
view on HN →